How To Troubleshoot A 4-20 mA Transmitter

4-20 mA transmitters are common in industrial automation and control; they are easy to install and easy to wire, the issue is that when they fail, most engineers struggle to troubleshoot them.

In this post i will share how to troubleshoot a 4-20 mA transmitter using just a multimeter.

What can cause a malfunctioning transmitter?

There are many things that can cause your transmitter to malfunction. The first thing to do is determine where the problem is. Problems can be caused by power, wiring, or loop device issues.

Instruments you need to troubleshoot a 4-20 mA transmitter

To troubleshoot a 4-20 mA loop electrically, you need a multimeter. The Multimeter should be able to read Volts and milliAmps DC.

You can find a multimeter in the hardware stores, auto parts stores, and department stores or buy it online.

multimeter

How to troubleshoot A 4-20 mA Transmitter

During troubleshooting i like to divide the transmitter into three sections: the output signal (this is the 4-20 mA signal), the transmitter itself and the power source or the input.

The 4-20 ma loop

If your controller does not get the signal, please disconnect the transmitter from the controller and use a multimeter to measure the 4-20 mA.

When there is nothing on the sensor, the output should be 4 mA, and when the transmitter is at half range, the output should be 12 mA, and at full range, it should be 20 mA.

If the loop does not appear to function in any manner, then you can go and check the power and wiring.

If it appears that the loop is functioning in some manner, then the nature of the malfunction becomes important.

If the only malfunction is that the display in the controller is reading the wrong numbers, then you should first investigate setting up the display. 

Please refer to the controller manual or the setting-up document in this series. Otherwise, start with the loop device section.

How to measure a 4-20 mA loop signal

Power

If the output you are getting is less than 4 mA, it is either the power supply or the wiring.

The first step in troubleshooting any circuit is to check the power supplies. Measure the loop power supply voltage, and ensure that it is at the proper level.

1) If the supply output is zero, determine if the supply is being powered, if a fuse is blown, or if the supply is damaged.

2) If the supply voltage is a little low, check to see if the supply is unregulated. Variation of the output voltage with load is normal for an unregulated supply.

3) If the supply is regulated and the output is low, it may be caused by a high loop load. Disconnect the loop and measure the voltage output.

If the source is bad or there is a faulty fuse, you will need to fix it or replace it depending on what applies to you.

Wiring

Check the wiring. The power supply + terminal should be run to the + terminal of the first item in the loop. 

The – terminal of the first item on the loop should be run to the + terminal of the second item on the loop, and so on until the wiring returns to the – terminal of the power supply.

With the loop supply powered, measure the voltages across the devices in the loop. 

The voltages on the loop devices should agree with the specifications for those devices, and the voltage polarity must agree with the + and – of the terminal block.

If the voltages across all the loop devices are zero, and the loop supply is within specification, then there is a break in the loop. 

If most, if not all, of the voltage occurs across any one of the loop devices, then there is a problem with that device.

The transmitter

Troubleshooting a transmitter depends on the type of the transmitter. The most important troubleshooting step is to make sure that it is wired properly. 

Most transmitters I have ever worked with have displays; if this is the case, usually they will show you an error code or warning, you can check that code on the transmitter user guide, and you can get an idea of what you are dealing with.

Another thing you can check here is the LED lights, in most transmitters, RED means alarm, yellow means the transmitter is at fault, and Green means it is working, this is not in all of them; you need to verify in the user guide for the specific transmitter.

Key takeaways

Most issues with the transmitter are due to wrong wiring; please make sure that they are wired properly. Transmitters can be damaged by attaching power to the wrong terminals.

If the device is wired properly, measure the voltage across the transmitter to check the polarity and to make sure that it has sufficient voltage to operate by comparing the measured voltage to the minimum in the specifications for that transmitter.

Sensors must be properly attached; check the wiring diagram for the transmitter to ensure that it is proper.

If you do all of that and the transmitter still is at fault, you need to contact the manufacturer for further troubleshooting and possible return of the transmitter to the manufacturer.

How To Design A Gas Detection System For Boiler Rooms

We commonly use natural gas for heating in industrial complexes; undetected gas leaks or incomplete combustion could cause an explosive hazard or an influx of carbon monoxide, resulting in loss of life, structural damage, or expensive waste of fuel.

Why do we need a gas detection system for boiler rooms?

The boiler room is not frequently occupied; this may lead to the leak remaining undetected.

A continuous gas monitoring and detection system will provide early warning of a gas leak and prevent loss of life and material.

What gases can be found in boiler rooms?

Natural gas

Natural gas is used in the industry for heating, and undetected leaks can be deadly. Nearly half of the natural gas is methane.

Since natural gas is lighter than air, it will immediately rise to the ceiling or roof space of the boiler room.

Carbon Monoxide

Carbon monoxide is the result of the incomplete burning of hydrocarbon fuels such as wood products, natural gas, fuel oil, and coal.

For this reason, carbon monoxide and natural gas monitoring are essential for gas detection in boiler rooms.

Components of Boiler room gas detection system

The boiler room’s gas detection system consists of sensors that are strategically placed to detect natural gas and carbon monoxide, with a controller that will have relays or that can connect to an external system.

Gas sensors

I recommend selecting catalytic bead sensors for boiler room applications. Catalytic bead sensors are less prone to false alarms than solid-state or semiconductor sensors.

Catalytic bead sensors have a life expectancy of 3 to 5 years, sometimes even more depending on how well you take care of them and environmental factors like temperature and humidity.

Boiler rooms are considered safe areas, i.e., you do not need explosion-proof sensors, but it is recommended to use them, and if possible, use class I Div I sensors.

My recommendation for this would be Sensepoint XCD or E3point, both manufactured by Honeywell.

Location of the sensors

Natural gas is lighter than air, which means the gas will concentrate near the roof, so my recommendation would be to place at least one sensor on the roof (typically one foot from the roof), and the rest of the sensors should be located over potential leak areas.

This includes

  • The gas burner assembly.
  • The gas train assembly.
  • The pressure boosters (if boosted).
  • The gas shut-off valve.
  • The combustion air intake.
  • The gas meter.

Depending on the size of the boiler room, the rule of thumb is to install one sensor for each 25 feet of radius.

The controller

It is recommended to have at least one controller in the boiler room; as its name suggests, the controller will be the main brain of the gas detection system. You can set it up to shut down the valves, activate relays, or activate the horn and strobe.

Here are my recommendations when it comes to selecting a controller for the boiler room gas detection system.

Location of the controller

I recommend having a controller outside the boiler room so that people can see what is going on in the boiler room before they enter it.

Compatible with the sensors

I have seen people buy sensors from one manufacturer and the controller from a different one, or the same manufacturer, but they are incompatible.

Make sure the sensors you have can communicate with the controller; if you have 4-20 mA sensors, you need a controller that can take 4-20 mA input; if the sensors are Modbus, make sure the controller can accept Modbus inputs.

The controller must have relays

Depending on what you want to do, you may need a controller with relays; this can be to shut down a control valve, start or stop a fan, process, etc.

Power Supply

Most controllers run on 24 VDC; make sure that you have the power supply that can help the sensors and the controller.

Visible Display

I recommend a controller that has a visible display so that people can be able to see the reading in real-time.

Integration Options

Depending on whether the boiler room gas detection system is stand-alone or is integrated with a larger system.

If you are going to connect it to a building management system (BMS), you probably need a controller that has BACnet (Building Automation Control Network) protocol as an output.

FAQ: Gas Detection System For Boiler Rooms

What detector do you need for a boiler room?

You need two types of detectors for carbon monoxide and flammable gases (LEL).

How many sensors do I need for a boiler room?

It depends on how many potential leaks there are; I recommend one per potential leak. Make sure the sensors are placed near the potential leak.

Is a carbon monoxide detector required in a boiler room?

Each boiler room containing one or more boilers from which carbon monoxide can be produced shall be equipped with a carbon monoxide detector with a manual reset.

Key takeaways: Gas Detection System For Boiler Rooms

Most industries, including boiler rooms, use natural gas for heating; this poses the danger of explosion due to the natural gas leak, or the unburned gases can turn into carbon monoxide.

To design a gas detection system for boiler rooms, you need to consider sensors that will detect methane (LEL sensors) and carbon monoxide.

I recommend using electrochemical sensors because they have an expected life of 3 to 5 years and produce fewer false alarms.

You need to place the sensors near the position where there is more possibility of a leak and the controller outside the boiler room where it is visible so that people can see the reading before they enter the boiler room.